top of page
Untitled design (29).png
Untitled design (28).png

How to Write a Performance Marketing Brief That Gets Comparable Proposals

13 hours ago
8 min read
Write A Comparable Agency Brief — Blackbird Marketing process visual guide

By Blackbird Marketing

If you want comparable proposals from performance marketing agencies, give each one the same commercial problem, starting information, constraints and definition of success. A brief that only says “we need more leads” leaves agencies to make different assumptions about channels, tracking, budget and the work involved.

In short: Define the business outcome first, then document your audience, current position, available budget, assets, measurement and decision criteria. Ask every agency to separate recommendations, deliverables, fees and assumptions so you can compare like with like.

Start with the decision the marketing must improve

A performance brief should begin with the decision or business result that matters, not with a list of platforms. For example, you may need more qualified enquiries, a lower cost per booked job, better visibility for a particular service or a clearer route from website visit to sale.

Be specific about what happens after a lead arrives. An enquiry form, telephone call, quote request and completed sale are not interchangeable outcomes. If an agency is judged on form submissions while your business needs profitable work, the proposals may look successful on paper but fail to answer the real question.


Write the objective in measurable terms

Use a short objective that connects marketing activity to a commercial measure. You do not need to know the answer before briefing agencies, but you should explain what you are trying to establish.

  • What service, product or area of the business needs support?

  • What action counts as a useful enquiry?

  • Which leads are unsuitable, too small, outside your area or unlikely to convert?

  • Is the immediate priority volume, lead quality, efficiency, revenue or learning?

  • What decision will you make after reviewing the results?


A small business may have several valid goals, but ranking them matters. “More traffic, more leads, stronger branding and lower costs” is not a practical priority list unless you explain which one wins when the objectives conflict.


Give agencies the same starting information

Comparable proposals depend on comparable inputs. Include enough context for an agency to understand the job, while avoiding a long history that does not affect the recommendation.

Your brief should normally cover:

  • Business model: what you sell, how customers buy and whether the sale is online, by telephone, through a quote or through another route.

  • Priority offer: the service or product you want to grow, including any work you do not want to attract.

  • Target audience: who makes the decision, what triggers the enquiry and what might prevent them from proceeding.

  • Location: the areas you can genuinely serve and any limits on travel, delivery or capacity.

  • Commercial context: useful information about margins, lead value, sales capacity and seasonal restrictions.

  • Current activity: channels used now, what has been tested and what you believe has or has not worked.

  • Available assets: website, landing pages, photography, customer information, brand material, tracking access and existing advertising accounts.


Do not ask an agency to guess whether your sales team can handle more enquiries, whether a service is available in a particular area or whether certain jobs are commercially worthwhile. Those details change the recommended approach and should be stated plainly.


Explain what a qualified lead means

Define a useful enquiry in terms the business can recognise. For one company, it may be a completed quote request from a serviceable area. For another, it may be a telephone call lasting long enough to discuss a viable project.

Also describe exclusions. If spam, jobseekers, existing customers, suppliers, unsuitable locations or low-value enquiries should not be counted, say so. Agencies can then explain how they would measure or filter those actions rather than reporting an inflated total.


Separate the channel question from the business problem

A brief should invite a reasoned recommendation rather than prescribe a channel without explanation. You may suspect that paid search, organic search, landing pages, email or social media is the answer, but the agency should show how the proposed activity connects to the stated objective.

Ask for the proposed role of each channel, what it is expected to influence and what would make the agency change direction. This is more useful than asking every agency to provide the same list of tactics, because different channels may be appropriate at different stages.


When a channel-led brief is still useful

If you already have a confirmed constraint, include it. For example, you may need help with PPC because an account exists and must be managed, or you may want SEO because the website needs sustained organic visibility. Be clear whether the agency may challenge that assumption.

For a trades or property-related business, the distinction between a click, an enquiry and a booked job is particularly important. A campaign that generates attention but attracts work you cannot service is not meeting the commercial objective.

Blackbird Marketing publishes services including local SEO for trades, PPC for trades and digital marketing for tradespeople. If one of those areas is relevant, use the brief to ask whether the listed service fits the specific job rather than assuming that a broad service label answers every requirement. You can review the business website service information when the website or landing-page foundation is part of the decision.


Set out the measurement and data position

Agencies cannot give genuinely comparable performance proposals if each one assumes a different measurement system. Tell them what is currently tracked, where leads are recorded and whether the data can be trusted.

Include, where available:

  • analytics and advertising accounts that are already in use;

  • the actions currently counted as conversions;

  • telephone tracking or call records;

  • customer relationship management or sales records;

  • historic campaign data and date ranges;

  • known gaps, duplicated conversions or tracking changes;

  • who will confirm whether an enquiry became a suitable opportunity or sale.


If you do not have reliable historic data, state that clearly. An agency should then explain what it would establish first and how early reporting would differ from later performance assessment. Avoid presenting estimates as existing benchmarks.


Ask agencies to define their figures

Terms such as leads, conversions, acquisition cost, return and qualified opportunities can mean different things. Ask each proposer to define the measures it will use, identify the data source and explain which figures are forecasts rather than observed results.

Also ask whether media spend, management fees, creative work, website changes, tracking and third-party software are included or separate. This is one of the simplest ways to prevent two apparently similar proposals from covering different amounts of work.


Give a budget range without asking for false precision

A budget helps agencies recommend a realistic scope. If you cannot state a firm figure, provide a working range or explain the financial limit that matters, such as an acceptable cost per qualified opportunity or the amount available for an initial test.

Ask agencies to show what their recommendation assumes about:

  • advertising spend and management fees;

  • strategy, copy, design and landing-page work;

  • technical implementation and tracking;

  • content production or website changes;

  • testing and reporting;

  • work expected from your own team.


A low fee may reflect a narrower scope rather than better value. Conversely, a larger proposal may include work you do not need. The useful comparison is not the headline price; it is the cost and likely contribution of the defined work.


Specify the response format so proposals can be compared

Ask every agency to answer the same questions and keep the response to a practical length. This reduces the risk that a polished presentation hides missing information.

A useful response structure is:

  1. Understanding of the problem: what the agency believes you are trying to improve.

  2. Recommended approach: channels, priorities and the reason for choosing them.

  3. First work package: what would be checked, changed or built before ongoing activity.

  4. Deliverables: the actual outputs, not just broad activity labels.

  5. Measurement: conversion definitions, reporting and data requirements.

  6. Assumptions and dependencies: access, approvals, content, sales follow-up and website changes.

  7. Fees and exclusions: one-off work, recurring work, media spend and optional items.

  8. Risks and alternatives: what may limit results and what the agency would test instead.


Request a clear distinction between recommendations and commitments. A proposal can outline a sensible direction without promising a particular number of leads or a fixed commercial result. Be cautious of any response that uses certainty where the agency has not seen your data, market conditions or sales process.


Ask for a like-for-like first phase

If agencies suggest different channel mixes, ask each to price a comparable initial scope as well as its preferred option. That might mean a defined audit, tracking review, campaign plan or landing-page assessment, depending on the problem.

This lets you compare the cost of becoming ready, while still allowing an agency to explain why its wider recommendation differs. It also exposes proposals that depend on substantial unpriced work from your team.

For a wider discussion of comparing proposals where agencies recommend different channels, see How to Compare Marketing Agency Proposals When Channels Differ.


Include the practical constraints that affect delivery

Tell agencies who approves content, how quickly changes can be reviewed and which parts of the website or advertising account cannot be altered. These are not administrative details: they affect what can be tested and how quickly learning can be applied.

Also state whether you can supply photographs, service information, customer FAQs, technical access or sales feedback. If the agency is expected to write or build assets, ask it to identify the inputs required and any work outside the quoted scope.

Do not describe an internal approval or reporting process as settled if it has not been agreed. Instead, ask the agency to propose a workable arrangement and state what your business would need to provide.


Use a fair evaluation scorecard

Before proposals arrive, decide how you will assess them. A simple scorecard prevents the cheapest response or the most confident presentation from dominating the decision.

Consider scoring each proposal against:

  • understanding of the commercial objective;

  • fit between the recommendation and your audience, offer and capacity;

  • clarity of deliverables and ownership;

  • quality and realism of measurement;

  • transparency of fees, media spend and exclusions;

  • amount of work required from your team;

  • ability to explain risks and change course;

  • relevance of experience, without treating unsupported claims as proof.


Keep the scorecard tied to the brief. Do not award points for claims you cannot verify or for a long list of services that are not relevant to the job.


Common briefing mistakes to avoid


Writing the answer into the brief

Insisting on a particular platform or tactic can prevent agencies from identifying a better route. If the channel is non-negotiable, explain why; otherwise ask for the reasoning behind the recommendation.


Using vague success language

“Grow the brand” or “improve performance” may be valid ambitions, but they are not enough to compare proposals. Attach each broad aim to an observable action, commercial measure or decision point.


Hiding inconvenient information

Previous activity, weak tracking, limited capacity or poor-quality enquiries should be disclosed. An agency cannot price or plan around a constraint it does not know exists.


Comparing different scopes as if they were identical

Check whether each proposal includes the same type of strategy, implementation, creative, reporting and account management. If not, record the difference rather than treating the headline fee as a direct comparison.


A practical one-page brief structure

You can keep the main document short and attach supporting information separately. The core brief should answer these questions in order:

  1. What business result needs to improve?

  2. Which offer and audience are in scope?

  3. Where can the business operate and what capacity limits apply?

  4. What has been tried and what evidence is available?

  5. What assets, access and internal support exist?

  6. What budget, timing constraints and dependencies should agencies consider?

  7. How will a qualified enquiry, opportunity or sale be identified?

  8. What must each proposal include and how will it be assessed?


Send the same version to each agency, give the same deadline and provide the same opportunity to ask clarification questions. If you change an important fact or answer one agency privately, share that clarification with all shortlisted providers.


When an agency proposal is ready to compare

A useful proposal should make its logic visible. You should be able to see the link between your objective, the recommended activity, the required inputs, the measures and the cost. If you cannot explain what each part is meant to do, ask for clarification before comparing prices.

The strongest brief is not the longest one. It is the one that removes avoidable assumptions while leaving room for an agency to apply judgement. That gives a Hertfordshire small business a fairer basis for choosing the right scope, not simply the most persuasive document.

Ready to discuss the website side of the brief? If your marketing plan depends on a clearer website or landing-page foundation, review the business website service and contact Blackbird Marketing to ask whether it suits the job.

 
 
bottom of page